Recalibrating What the NCAA Tournament Means
The question of which team deserves more praise -- the Ohio State or Kansas that dominated the regular season but didn't make the Final Four, or the UConn or Butler who struggled throughout the season but got hot at the end -- is highly debatable and perhaps not possible to answer. But what is possible is to make a distinction between types of greatness, and to recognize that greatness can happen at any time, not just the end of a season.
For all the problems the BCS has (and they are myriad), I think that one game does a better job of determining the champion of the sport than the NCAA basketball tournament. And for all of college football fans' sturm und drang about the BCS, we hear not but mere peeps about the NCAA tournament's "inverse BCS" problem.
While the BCS eliminates teams that may have a claim to be the best from consideration for the "national championship", at least the team that does win will also have a claim to be the best. In the NCAA basketball tournament, so many teams participate that are not even close to the best that very often, this year included, upsets will occur and a team like Butler or UConn will be in position to be named "national champion." These are inverse but similarly troubling problems.
about 1 year ago
Jeremy Mauss
2 comments
2 recs |
Comments
I think I agree with this.
The regular season quite simply doesn’t mean as much in terms of determining the National Championship as it does in football. Now, that doesn’t mean that if there were a playoff in college football that the same would happen there, but it simply means that the NCAA Tournament should be contracted so that it makes the regular season mean more in terms of determining a National Champion.
Mountain West Connection - All you need to know about the Mountain West and then some.
Stampede Blue - An Indianapolis Colts blog.
Bright Side of the Sun - Dedicated to Phoenix Suns basketball since 2006.
UNLV is going to have 6 losses this year!
The Suns are going to be 57-25 in the regular season this year!
;)
Twitter: @rebelfan1_
Basketball is more random than football
And Division I has far too many schools to stage a best-of-3 tournament (conference champs only would have over 32 schools), let alone an NBA style best of 7 every round tournament (the NBA has the most predictable postseason of any major American sport, because it’s a less random sport than baseball or hockey, but plays best of 7 playoff series anyway).





















