Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Animated GIFs Of January

Ranking The Mountain West Coaches


With the season nearly three weeks away it is time to start counting down the best players in the league in their respective position group. These lists will be a top 10 list broken down into 10-6 and then 5-1 to add some sort of suspense or intrigue.  Today begins with counting down the coaches and it will be just one post for all the teams. The rankings are based on the coaches record and success or failure within their league which is why UNLV's head man Bobby Hauck is not ranked.

These rankings reflect how the staff voted here at the site 

NR. Bobby Hauck, UNLV

His prior spot was at Montana where he won or shared the Big Sky conference title in his seven years, and took the Grizzlies to three FCS title appearances.
8. Mike Locksley, New Mexico 
(1 season 1-11)

If I had chosen to rank Bobby Hauck I would have probably ranked him behind Locksley.  Last year was terrible with Locksley being accused of ageism, sexual harassment, and punched an assistant coach.  He better hope his recruiting efforts are really that good.

7. Brady Hoke, San Diego State  (1 season, 4-8)

Hoke has the weapons on offense but the defense gave up way too many points.  Hoke has infused some umph to the program which badly needs it.  Expect some big things for the Aztecs under Hoke.

6.  Steve Fairchild, Colorado State (2 seasons, 10-15)

Year one was good by winning the New Mexico Bowl and big things were expected last year with the most experienced offensive line in the nation and a three and zero start.  Then the bottom fell out with a nine game losing streak.  Quarterback issues last year were an issue, but expect this year to be better with four star recruit Peter Thomas most likely being the starting quarterback.

Star-divide


5. Dave Christensen, Wyoming  (1 season, 7-6)

His coaching job in year one was nothing short of brillant.  The last few years of Joe Glenn were not kind with recruiting or building tough players.  Glenn was a loved figure but he lost his touch the last few years and never put the Pokes over the top.  Look for Wyoming to struggle this year, but they will be much more improved with a full year of his spread scheme under the belts of the offense.
4. Troy Calhoun, Air Force 
(3 seasons, 25-14)

Calhoun really gets lost in the shadow in this league, but he has gone to three straight bowl games with a single bowl win.  Calhoun kept the tradition of good football that former head coach Foghorn Leghorn Fisher DeBerry by keeping the triple option alive.  What Calhoun has done that is different is the defense that has been established which was 11th in the nation last year.

3. Bronco Mendenhall, BYU  (5 seasons, 49-15)

Bronco has the same amount of conference titles as TCU's Gary Patterson, but has yet to make it to a BCS bowl game which is the reason for the the third spot.  His teams are always well disciplined and as you will read under Kyle Whittingham's blurb BYU rarely gets blown out.  

He has brought BYU back to the national spotlight which was lost under Gary Crowton and Mendenhall's first year, but  has guided BYU to ten or more games and finished in the top-25 four consecutive times.
2. Gary Patterson, TCU (10 seasons, 85-28)

 

After a 12-1 2009 season that included TCU's first ever appearance in a BCS Bowl TCU Head Coach Gary Patterson received 9 different "Coach of the Year" awards.  Coach Patterson is entering his 10th season as head coach of the Frogs and boasts a record of 85-28 (.752).  A defensive "guru" Patterson believes in one thing above all else when looking for talent, "Speed Baby!" 

1. Kyle Whittingham, Utah  (5 seasons, 47-17)

The main reason Whittingham is here is because he has won a BCS bowl game where Gary Patterson has not.  The only down year for Utah that was really Whittinghams team was 2006 in the year without Brian Johnson where the team was off and on.  His teams rarely get blown out with the loan exceptions being a 27-0 beat down in 2007 to UNLV, and last years waxing by TCU.  Overall his team is always prepared.

Follow Mountain West Connection via Twitter and Facebook for News Quick Hits and Random Nonsense.


Comment 13 comments  |  Add comment  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Around SB Nation

NCAA Football 2010 goodies

Jul 2009 from Block U - 1 comment

Matt Hinton's flawed logic

Jul 2009 from Block U - 11 comments

Playing the percentage game

Aug 2009 from Block U - 27 comments

Comments

Display:

Did the rankings I sent you get in?

It doesn’t look like it and I just wanted to make sure that it did.

Mountain West Connection - The best site for MWC Sports.
UNLV is going all the way this year!

by rebelfan1 on Aug 10, 2010 7:20 PM PDT reply actions  

it was a combination of voters

I should specify that at the beginning.

Mountain West Connection The best site for MWC sports!

by Jeremy Mauss on Aug 10, 2010 7:26 PM PDT up reply actions  

plus

I should have mentioned about not ranking Hauck since its his first year.

Mountain West Connection The best site for MWC sports!

by Jeremy Mauss on Aug 10, 2010 7:28 PM PDT reply actions  

Hoke is underrated, as he did get Ball State to a 12-0 regular season, even after they lost their all star wideout. I’d slide him into #5, no question.

Also no problems with Patterson being #2. The man is a defensive genius, but I’ve never been a fan of his offensive gameplans.

by HawkeyedFrog on Aug 10, 2010 7:29 PM PDT reply actions  

Hoke

is low because these rankings are for MWC play only.

Mountain West Connection The best site for MWC sports!

by Jeremy Mauss on Aug 10, 2010 7:37 PM PDT up reply actions  

Here's my case for Bronco

If speed and talent are the things that everyone says hurts BYU then Bronco is the freaking man for making untalented slow white guys 10 game winners. Plus, he’s done all of this coming out of a very down period in BYU history with Crowton.

Whitt on the other hand has had highs and lows but you have to contribute the 2008 season to what Meyer did in the 2004 season. All the players in the 2008 season were recruited based on the success from 2004. For that reason I have yet to give Whitt too much credit because last year was the first year we actually saw Whitt’s own team.

Bronco walked into nothing, Whitt walked into everything. Bronco should be #1… plus he has the best record and win pct.

by vaughnzipper on Aug 10, 2010 8:56 PM PDT reply actions  

yes and no

I can see where Bronco could be number one, because it really is close but the BCS games are what is keeping him behind. In the biggest games he has come up short TCU ’08, TCU ’09, and FSU ’09 to name a few.

The Urban Meyer affect was a boost but I dont think it was a key reason that Utah went unbeaten in 08. I think Whitt and Bronco get the most out their players. Whitt moves players around to get the best out of them, and as you said BYU is a bunch of white guys where some seem slow and not an uber talent but they make it work.

Mountain West Connection The best site for MWC sports!

by Jeremy Mauss on Aug 10, 2010 10:04 PM PDT up reply actions  

Bronco has won more conference titles then any of the coaches in the Mountain West

Actually, Mendenhall and Patterson both have two.

by Ute in DC on Aug 10, 2010 11:34 PM PDT reply actions  

Bronco walked into nothing, Whitt walked into everything. Bronco should be #1

Uh, Vaughn. You of all people should know 2005 was no picnic in Kyle’s eyes. He only won one more game than Bronco did so I don’t think he “inherited everything”. Let us also remember that several high profile recruits de-commited when Urban Meyer left for Florida. 2004 was a great year and did us many favors in recruiting but the bumps of 2005-07 were certainly backward steps. My point is give credit where it’s due:Kyle and Co. did a fantastic job in keeping their boys focused in 08’. Going undefeated means more than recruiting great talent.

But getting back to the issue at hand, you argue that Bronco should be ranked higher. Are you basing that completely on MWC titles and overall wins? That doesn’t cut it. Bronco will not be on Kyle’s or G. Patterson’s level until he does what they did….make a BCS bowl game. (Instead of printing Quest T-shirts)

by GambitUte on Aug 11, 2010 4:29 PM PDT reply actions  

You sound like a fool and you're lying to yourself

If you think that the success Utah had in 2004 didn’t help recruiting. I don’t care who you say “de-committed” it’s still going to help your recruiting. Besides, you say it wasn’t a picnic for Kyle, then what was it for Bronco? My point is that Bronco inherited a struggling program, KW cannot say that. Unless you want to admit that the 2004 Utah team was weak and that the BCS bowl wasn’t deserving. Kyle has maintained but Bronco has built.

You’re beyond arrogant and half retarded to say that Bronco won’t be on Whitt or Patty’s level until he gets a BCS game. So what you’re saying is that Whitt isn’t on the same level as Peterson of Boise St. because he has 2 BCS bowls to KW’s 1? I’d love to hear Utes admit that one. I mean, if you’re going to base opinion by deduction then that’s what you’re saying.

I love how Utes like to pick on the fact that BYU is full of slow white guys yet when the coach of the slow white guys has a better overall win record and a winning record against Utah they don’t want to admit that Bronco is better or as good as their coach. But hey, your logic makes sense… right?

In the end, pull off the red goggles gambit and recognize what Bronco’s worked to build and what KW has stepped into. It’s not that hard to see if you’d step back and look at the facts.

FYI –
2004 Season (pre BM and KW)
BYU 5-6
Utah 12-0
2005 Season (1st year for both)
BYU 6-6
Utah 7-5

KW’s 1st year was a picnic compared to Bronco’s.

by vaughnzipper on Aug 11, 2010 5:32 PM PDT reply actions  

Sorry Vaughn I'm not taking the bait...

This post is to discuss rankings of MWC coaches . Not Bronco Vs Kyle…I can argue with you on your turf but I’m not gonna continue this silly discussion here.

by GambitUte on Aug 11, 2010 6:05 PM PDT reply actions  

Ummm... Bait?

I sense it’s more of a lack of support for your argument. It’s not about BM v KW but when you’re arrogant to say BM is not even on the same level as KW and GP is just anothe Ute running his ignorant mouth.

by vaughnzipper on Aug 11, 2010 6:34 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions  


User Tools

Welcome to the Mountain West Connection we are dedicated to all things MWC. For Convenience follow us @ JeremyMauss via twitter.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
WAC That Should've Happened
Werder_small
Navy, the Big East and the "giant sucking sound"
Werder_small
"Dissolve" MW and C-USA and re-form?
Werder_small
The Mtn.: Get Active
Hillbillies_small
bowl pick'em second round results and third round format
Hillbillies_small
bowl pick'em round one results
Werder_small
New AD Jack Graham has big plans for CSU
Werder_small
2012 CSU Rams Helmet Concept Re-Design - Vote Now!
Hillbillies_small
come one, come all. second chance to be the top picker.
Nevada-logo3_small
Pick 'em Postseason - New Format (All Players Welcome!)

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Jer_small Jeremy Mauss

Authors

Pro-nedna-twitter-icon01_small Sam (sdsuaztec4)

6061-1_1__small rebelfan1

Img_0065__1__small greekpadre

Bsu_logo5_small bluesyourdaddy

Tcuflag_small Ben Findley

Commander_in_chiefs_trophy_small airforcetwo

Nevada-logo3_small pack_fan

Nevada_wolf_pack_logo_small WolfpackNev

007_small Chris Holly Taylor

Werder_small jitmon

Capo_small Anthony Capobianco