The BCS computer rankings and the various other human polls this week have come out and caused a lot of dissension among many posters here, among other places. I think the biggest bone of contention for most of these rankings is the lack of objectivity; that is, many people think the rankings are too subjective. Now, this is obviously very crude, but I just wanted to see if it was possible to objectively rank teams, so I tried to set up an experiment. I'm not a mathematician or statistician by any means (I guess that makes me qualified to work for the BCS), but I do have a degree in political science, for what it's worth.
INSTRUCTIONS: I made up these numbers for the purposes of this experiment, so that's why they don't look realistic since they are all round numbers. What you need to do is to pick between TEAM A and TEAM B as to which you think is the better team based on the numbers in the chart below. Team A and Team B both played and won home games against the opponents, TEAM X and TEAM Y. The first column shows how both A and B fared in their wins against X. The second column shows how both A and B fared in their wins over team Y. For example, Team A gained 500 yards against Team X and allowed Team X to gain 250 yards, etc.
Obviously there are other immeasurable factors, but I tried to isolate as much as that as possible. Use your best football judgment.
|OPPONENT: Team X||OPPONENT: Team Y|
|Team A||Team B||Team A||Team B|
|Total Offensive Yards||500||410||450||370|
|Rushing Yards Gained||140||200||200||110|
|Passing Yards Gained||360||210||250||260|
|Total Yards Allowed||250||420||490||460|
|Rushing Yards Allowed||110||80||315||350|
|Passing Yards Allowed||140||340||175||110|
|AVG Yds Allowed/Play||3.5||5.5||5||6|
Which is the better football team?
Team A (40 votes)
Team B (0 votes)
About the same (9 votes)
49 total votes